The show.fm PODCAST

31 – Should you do a pre-recording interview for your podcast?

Released

Episode # 31

We’re doing something new with the podcast. So far, it’s been me, Nathan Wrigley, talking into the mic. That’s still going to happen, but we’re introducing a new format to help you on your podcasting journey – short, actionable content.

The idea is to have a conversation with an existing podcaster, and ask them to reveal ONE thing that they like about their podcasting setup. Hopefully you, dear listener, will find something of value here to improve the way that you create your podcast.

They might tell us about something they do during the recording. It could be a technical tip, or something they do when the mics are off. It’s up to them.

If you’d like to be a guest on this podcast, then head to show.fm/tips and fill out the form there.

So let’s get started.

Today I’m talking with Rob Cairn from Stunning Digital Marketing.

This episode takes a close look at the often-overlooked, and probably not often implemented, step of vetting guests before they ever get onto your podcast.

Rob explains the value of integrating a 15-minute pre-interview call for new guests. It’s a guardrail implemented after he experienced ‘less-than-ideal’ guests.

Roc tells us how these pre-calls offer a chance to gauge a guest’s energy, discover whether their goals align with the show’s direction, and avoid wasting time on episodes that might never see the light of day.

We also get into how this pre-interview filters out about 10% of applicants who don’t quite fit, and how Rob’s processes occasionally need to adapt on the fly when unexpected requests pop up.

This is really all about direct communication, preferring to speak to the actual person appearing rather than an assistant or business partner, and how these authentic pre-show conversations can sometimes lead to genuine, off-air friendships.

Rob wraps up by encouraging all you podcasters to implement pre-interview steps not only as a quality control measure but also as a powerful way to build rapport and enhance every recorded conversation.

If you’re looking to strengthen your show’s guest vetting, streamline your process, and foster real connections in your community, you’ll find plenty to inspire you in this episode.

In the show.fm podcasting app, we have an interesting way of tackling this problem for you. Not only can the booking form allow you to create your own set of questions so you can understand more about your guest, but you also get show.fm to carry out background research on your guest before you click ‘confirm’ on their application.

In addition to that, we also allow you to create automatic email sequences so your guest knows exactly where to be and exactly when to be there.

Key Topics Covered

Introduction to the Podcast

  • Overview of the show.fm podcast and its focus on simplifying and automating podcasting 00:06
  • Announcement of a new conversational format with existing podcasters
  • Aim to share practical tips and insights from podcasting experiences

Guest Introduction and Podcast Background

  • Introduction of Rob Cairns from Stunning Digital Marketing 00:46
  • Cairns’ podcast origins during the 2020 COVID era
  • Evolution from casual beginnings to achieving 704 episodes 01:23
  • Primary focus: WordPress, marketing, business strategies, and recent attention to AI in the industry

Pre-Interview Call Process

  • Description of implementing a 15-minute pre-podcast interview for guests who are not personally known 02:02
  • Purpose:
    • Gauge guests’ energy, intentions, and fit for the show
    • Protect the show from inappropriate or misaligned guests
  • Occasions when the pre-interview is skipped, notably with recurring or well-known guests

Trigger for Implementing Pre-Interview

  • Past negative experience with a misrepresented guest leading to an unairable episode 02:53
  • Use of pre-interviews as a guardrail to prevent wasted time and problematic recordings
  • Acknowledgement that the system isn’t foolproof and some issues may still arise

Handling Guest Requests and Red Flags

  • Examples of guests or their assistants sending in post-pre-interview demands, such as requesting predetermined questions 03:42
  • Stance on cancelling recordings when requests diverge from agreed terms 03:48
  • Emphasis on show fit being more important than potential guest reach or follower count 03:53

Management of Pre-Interview Workflow

  • Typical timeline between pre-interview and actual recording (often 1-2 weeks) 04:41
  • Booking process includes agreeing to terms of service and review of expectations before recording
  • Occasional issues with guests claiming not to have read the terms, despite clear instructions 05:08

Depth of Pre-Interview Process

  • Limiting the process to a single pre-interview call in most cases 04:41
  • Ensuring guests receive and acknowledge terms before proceeding
  • Only one question provided ahead of time: why the guest entered their respective industry, with special interest in WordPress backgrounds 05:43

Effectiveness and Metrics of Guest Screening

  • Rough estimation that about 10% of potential guests are identified as not being a fit through this process 06:32
  • Low incidence of unairable or cancelled episodes compared to total number of recorded shows 06:34

Ensuring Direct Communication with Guests

  • Policy that only the intended guest (not assistants or secretaries) may participate in pre-interview calls and fill out booking forms 07:14
  • Requirement that all people appearing on the show (including business partners) must attend the pre-interview 07:49
  • Strict adherence to speaking directly with guests before recordings are scheduled

Additional Benefits of Pre-Interview Meetings

  • Discovery of guest backgrounds and personalities that enrich the recorded episode 08:09
  • Occasional development of off-air rapport and even friendships 08:37
  • Flexibility for more candid, off-the-record conversations that help tailor the main podcast discussion

Summary and Call to Action

  • Recap of the main tip: incorporating pre-interview calls to vet and prepare guests 08:49
  • Invitation for listeners to contribute their own podcasting tips on the show.fm website 09:13
  • Closing thanks and sign-off
Transcript

​

[00:00:06] Nathan Wrigley: Hello there and welcome to the show.fm podcast. The podcast offering tips and tricks to simplify and automate your podcast. You can find all the episodes at show.fm/show.

We’re trying something new out today. The idea is to have a conversation with an existing podcaster, and ask them to reveal one or maybe two, depending on how the guest is feeling, thing that they like about their podcasting set up. Hopefully, you, dear listener, will find something of value here to improve the way that you create your podcast.

Who knows, they might tell us something they do during their recording. It could be a technical tip, or something they do when the mics are switched off. It’s totally up to them.

So let’s get started with this first episode, because today I’m going to be speaking with Rob Cairns from Stunning Digital Marketing.

How you doing, Rob?

[00:00:56] Rob Cairns: Doing good, Nathan. Thanks for having me. Good morning.

[00:00:58] Nathan Wrigley: You are very welcome. Do you want to just tell us a little bit about your podcast, what it is that you do, and how long you’ve been doing it?

[00:01:05] Rob Cairns: Sure. I started a podcast in 2020, back in the days of COVID. It was funny. I was bored one day and said, I should do an interview, and then I should do one more, and then I should do one more. And you’re laughing because you know how this goes.

[00:01:22] Nathan Wrigley: That’s how it went, yeah.

[00:01:23] Rob Cairns: And that’s how it went. And as of yesterday, we published our 704th podcast. It’s very WordPressy, I’ll say that. But it’s also focuses on marketing business, business strategies. And unfortunately the two most dirtiest word in our business, AI.

[00:01:44] Nathan Wrigley: Okay, yeah. Which a few years ago wasn’t such of a dirty word, but now it’s definitely become one, hasn’t it?

Okay, so we’ve got you on the podcast so that you can offer some intuition as to something which has gone well in your podcast. What is that? What is the thing that you like, or are happy with about your process?

[00:02:02] Rob Cairns: The biggest thing I did with my process is long time ago, I had a rule that if I don’t know the guest, I have to jump on a 15 minute pre podcast interview call with that person ahead of time.

So if it’s somebody I know or a reoccurring guest, I don’t bother because there’s no point, and there’s reasons for doing that.

The first one is it gives me a feel for what they’re like, their energy, what they want to say, and then it tells me real quick if they’re going to be a good fit or not a good fit for the show.

[00:02:36] Nathan Wrigley: Can I ask, did that come about because of bad experiences? In other words, did you have guests on and you thought halfway through the recording, oh, this isn’t going to work out? I need a guardrail. I need some barrier between guests filling out my form and actually coming on my show.

[00:02:53] Rob Cairns: Exactly. I had a guest that really misrepresented, and I got into a show 10 minutes and realised I was not going to air that show. I was quite frank, and it was how fast I could get them off my podcast and stop wasting everybody’s time. It was one of those.

And to be fair, and it’s not foolproof. Because sometimes when you go through this process, you still have problems. And it’s funny because I had one just yesterday where I went through the process two weeks ago. It went great. We were all aligned to record. And then I got an email yesterday before doing a record from a VA with all kinds of requests that were not discussed in the pre-interview show and the call. And I just said, including, believe it or not, asking me the questions ahead of time.

And I said, nope. I think I’m just going to cancel it. I’ll be fair, I got, I received an email from the individual saying, oh, I’ve got thousands of followers. And my thought was yeah, you might have thousands of followers, but if you’re not the right fit, you’re not the right fit.

[00:04:06] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, yeah..

[00:04:08] Rob Cairns: Why, would you do this even?

So what I’m saying to you, you can put up all the guardrails but sometimes things happen, you know that.

[00:04:15] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah. Did you ever get into a whole series of calls? In other words, giving up let’s say 10 minutes of your time on a day before you actually do the recording? That’s generous, I think in many ways anyway. But have you ended up doing one or two where you thought okay, we’re not really comfortable here, but let’s see if we can work this out. Or is it just one little call, just check it out, and then yes or no from there?

[00:04:41] Rob Cairns: Usually it’s one, and it usually happens, usually a week to two weeks to. I know when I record, if I’m recording today, I’m probably not going to air that for two weeks anyway. Usually the process is one call. Then they’ll book.

And by the way, they go to my booking screen, there’s a, like you, there’s a terms of service that they have to agree to, and a pile of stuff.

So they get a link, they agree to all the questions. And then they’re good to go for the show, even after the pre-interview call. And I’ve still had people say, I didn’t read that.

[00:05:21] Nathan Wrigley: Okay. Yeah, yeah. Do you do any other kind of, let’s say, paper-based things? I don’t literally mean paper, but do you do other things that sort of wrap around that pre-interview call, I don’t know, create some show notes, or write down some questions and share them in a certain way? Or is it simply we’re going to hop on that call. That’s going to be the moment where we figure out if you’re a good fit or not, and we’ll take it from there.

[00:05:43] Rob Cairns: Usually that’s what I do. I always tell my guests, the only question I’ll ever give them ahead of time is, why did you get into the industry you’re in?

[00:05:54] Nathan Wrigley: Okay.

[00:05:54] Rob Cairns: I’m always curious. There’s always a story there. If it’s WordPress, certainly how did you get into the WordPress industry? But that’s the, generally as a rule, that’s the only question I’ll give them ahead, of time. I don’t give them.

[00:06:09] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah. So I know that you obviously like this process, but are you able to reveal to us, roughly speaking, how effective it is? So in other words, if the idea here is to catch guests who’ve booked on through your form who are not quite the fit that you wish they would be? How, as a percentage, how would you put that? Is it like 3, 5, 10, 15% of people that you say, we’re not a fit?

[00:06:32] Rob Cairns: It’s probably 10.

[00:06:33] Nathan Wrigley: Okay.

[00:06:34] Rob Cairns: Somewhere around there. But what I’ll also tell you is, of the number of people that have got into the podcast, I’ve only not aired three shows, and I’ve only cancelled three or four before air, because there was something like yesterday that went the wrong way. That does happen, but it’s not terrible.

[00:06:55] Nathan Wrigley: Do you insist upon speaking to the person? So in other words, you described a minute ago that you might be interacting with an assistant or something like that. I get quite a few emails from people who are obviously running the office. They might be an assistant or some sort of secretarial work or something like that.

I get a few emails and my response to that is, please will you get the actual person to fill out the form, because I want to speak to them. So no, I won’t allow the assistant to book it. Do you make sure that is the person that’s on the call, the person doing it? So it’s not a, it’s not a fact finding mission, it’s a I want to know you mission.

[00:07:34] Rob Cairns: Yep, it is. And I’ll give you, and it’s, I’ll go one more step further. If you’re going to bring on your business partner with you on the show, because I’ve done a show, I’ve done shows where there’s two people on. Your business partner better be on that call. And that was part of yesterday’s problem, where the person said, the VA said, oh, I want the business partner. I said, no you don’t. He wasn’t on the pre-interview call. That’s not my process. No.

[00:08:01] Nathan Wrigley: Do you?

[00:08:02] Rob Cairns: I’m hard and fast about that.

[00:08:04] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, no, fair enough. Do you find there’s any other benefits that kind of smuggle themselves into this? In other words, let’s say for example, I don’t know, you just end up finding something out which was curious, which would never have been revealed anyway, because you get into a chat, it’s much more off air. Nobody’s hit record, so you’re probably a little bit freer with what you can say. So you might find things out about them or you might stray into different topics that you can cover.

So I’m just wondering if there’s any ancillary benefits for doing it? Not just are you a good fit? Yeah.

[00:08:36] Rob Cairns: All kinds of stuff. You learn more about the person. I’ve actually had friendships developed just out of that pre-call, believe it or not.

[00:08:43] Nathan Wrigley: Great.

[00:08:44] Rob Cairns: So it does happen. Yeah, all the time.

[00:08:47] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, in that case, I think that’s the perfect tip. To sum it up I guess, what you are saying is that, a good idea is to put in some kind of pre-call. If you’ve got the capacity to do that, just to figure out if the people that have filled out your booking form not only are the people that are actually going to come on the show, but if they’re a good fit for it.

Yeah, thank you Rob for chatting to me today. I really appreciate it.

[00:09:09] Rob Cairns: My pleasure.

[00:09:10] Nathan Wrigley: So there you go. That’s what we’ve got for you this time around. If you’d like to come on the show and talk to us about your quick podcasting tip, head to show.fm/tips and fill out the form there.

Thank you very much for tuning into the show.fm podcast. You can find it at show.fm/show. And we will see you next time for some more tips and tricks to simplify and automate your podcast.

Thanks, Rob.

[00:09:36] Rob Cairns: You’re welcome.

Filed under:

,